The Absolute Best Pizza in Bryn Mawr [Updated 2025]

Each bite of a perfectly baked slice tells a story, and let me tell you, Bryn Mawr has some captivating tales to share. Picture this: the warm, cheesy aroma wafting through the air, the satisfying crunch of a golden crust giving way to a burst of flavor with every delicious mouthful. I’ve scoured 12 top pizzerias in this charming little town, savoring everything from classic Margheritas to inventive gourmet toppings, and I can’t wait to take you along on this flavorful journey.

As someone who has spent years indulging in the art of pizza, I promise you my taste buds are finely tuned to discern the good from the truly great. So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, let’s dive into the best slices Bryn Mawr has to offer—your next favorite pizza spot is just a few bites away!

Johnny's Pizza Bryn Mawr

Highlights
Friendly and accommodating staff
Best cheesesteaks in Bryn Mawr
Crispy bread, soft inside
Local gem with a unique atmosphere
Generous portion sizes

Johnny's Pizza Bryn Mawr has become a delightful stop on my journey to find the best pizza in town. From the moment I entered, I was welcomed by the friendly and accommodating staff, who radiated warmth and enthusiasm. The atmosphere is charming—there’s a local gem vibe that makes you feel right at home.

Now, let’s talk about the food. While I came for the pizza, I couldn’t resist trying their renowned cheesesteaks and, wow, they did not disappoint! With crispy bread that yields to a soft interior, each bite was a perfect balance. The portion sizes are generous; you’re definitely getting your money’s worth here!

As for the pizza, I savored a classic Margherita. The fresh toppings paired beautifully with a perfectly baked crust, showcasing the chef's expertise. It may not have been the star of the show, but it complemented my meal wonderfully.

Whether you're indulging in a slice of pizza or sinking your teeth into a cheesesteak, Johnny's is a delightful spot that captures the very essence of Bryn Mawr's culinary scene. I left with a smile, satisfied and eager to return for another bite!

You might also want to check out the best philly cheesesteak in Philadelphia.

Exit 13

Highlights
Excellent food and service
Modern and clean environment
Friendly and knowledgeable staff
Diverse and appealing menu
Highly recommended for all occasions

At Exit 13, I found myself immersed in an atmosphere that perfectly balances modernity and comfort. Upon stepping inside, the clean environment and inviting decor set a delightful tone for what was to come.

The menu is impressively diverse – they cater to all kinds of pizza lovers. I decided to try their signature pie, and let me tell you, it was a symphony of flavors! The crust was golden and crisp, while the toppings were generous and fresh, making each bite a little celebration of taste. What made the experience even better was the service; the staff was not only friendly, but also incredibly knowledgeable about the menu options. Their recommendations were spot on, which enhanced my enjoyment.

Whether you’re looking for a quick meal or somewhere to celebrate a special occasion, Exit 13 checks all the boxes. I highly recommend this pizza haven for both locals and visitors alike. Definitely make this your next pizza destination; you won’t regret it! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Philadelphia.

Otto By Polpo

Highlights
Exceptional octopus dish
Reasonable prices
Delicious chicken picata
Inviting atmosphere
Flawless linguine pescatora

Otto By Polpo is a delightful gem tucked away in Bryn Mawr, and it’s not just the pizza that makes it shine. As I settled into the inviting atmosphere, I was greeted by the enticing aroma of freshly baked dough and savory toppings. The ambiance is warm and welcoming, perfect for a casual evening or a special occasion.

Now, let’s talk pizza! I ordered the classic Margherita, and it truly delivered. The crust was thin and perfectly crispy, while the tomato sauce burst with flavor, creating a delightful harmony with the fresh mozzarella. Each bite was a celebration of Italian tradition, making it clear why this place is loved by locals.

However, what truly stole my heart was their exceptional octopus dish; I never expected to be raving about seafood in a pizza review! The delicious chicken picata served alongside also deserves a shout-out for its rich, savory flavors.

And let’s not forget the flawless linguine pescatora—a perfect seafood accompaniment that balanced my meal beautifully. With such reasonable prices, Otto By Polpo is a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast in Bryn Mawr. I’m already planning my next trip!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Philadelphia.

Fellini Cafe Bryn Mawr

Highlights
Great ambiance and decor
Attentive and friendly service
Delicious homemade pasta
Filling and satisfying portions
Warm and inviting atmosphere

Review of Fellini Cafe Bryn Mawr

Stepping into Fellini Cafe Bryn Mawr is like crossing into a cozy Italian retreat right in Bryn Mawr, and let me tell you, the experience did not disappoint! The ambiance is inviting—with charming decor that wraps you in warmth as soon as you walk through the door. The staff was attentive and friendly, adding to the overall delightful atmosphere.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza—ah, the pizza! Each slice is a delightful marriage of crispy crust, zesty sauce, and rich cheese that keeps you coming back for more. With generous portions, you won't find yourself leaving hungry. I must say, their homemade pasta is a fantastic complement to the pizza, giving diners an array of choices that will satisfy any craving.

If you’re after a place that beautifully balances delicious food and a warm, inviting environment, Fellini Cafe should definitely be on your list. It’s a charming spot where flavor meets heartfelt hospitality—perfect for a casual evening or a cozy date night. Trust me, you won’t regret indulging in their mouthwatering offerings!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Philadelphia.

Tandoori Pizza - Bryn Mawr

Tandoori Pizza - Bryn Mawr is a delightful culinary fusion that brings a twist to the classic pizza experience. The moment I walked in, the aroma of spices teased my senses, promising something unique. I opted for the Tandoori Chicken Pizza, and I was not disappointed! The crispy crust perfectly complemented the bold flavors of tandoori chicken and fresh veggies. Each bite was a wonderful dance of spices that made my taste buds sing! If you’re in the mood for a pizza adventure, Tandoori Pizza is a must-visit for a playful yet satisfying meal. Deliciously different!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in King of Prussia.

Snap Custom Pizza

At Snap Custom Pizza, creativity meets flavor in a delightful symphony! The build-your-own concept allows you to craft your dream pizza, from crust to toppings. I opted for their signature thin crust, which was perfectly crispy and lightly charred. The freshness of the ingredients really stood out, especially the vibrant veggies and rich sauces. One bite in, and I was hooked! The staff was friendly and the ambiance was casual, making it a perfect spot for a quick lunch or a fun dinner. Overall, Snap Custom Pizza is a must-try for pizza enthusiasts! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Philadelphia.

Sun Valley Pizza and Catering

During my visit to Sun Valley Pizza and Catering, I was immediately struck by the inviting aroma wafting from the kitchen. The thin crust was expertly crisped to perfection, providing a delightful crunch with each bite. I opted for the classic pepperoni, and the generous portions of melty cheese paired beautifully with the perfectly spiced sauce. The balance of flavors was nothing short of spectacular. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, it's clear that Sun Valley is a beloved local gem. If you're seeking a slice of pizza heaven in Bryn Mawr, this place should definitely be on your radar!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Bensalem.

Lovecchio's Pizza

At Lovecchio's Pizza, I was instantly charmed by the inviting atmosphere that wraps around you like a warm hug. The thin-crust pizza stole the show—perfectly crispy with a delightful char, it offered a symphony of flavors. I tried the classic Margherita, adorned with fresh basil and luscious mozzarella. Each bite was a celebration of simplicity and quality, truly captivating! Not to forget, the staff was incredibly friendly, making the visit even more enjoyable. If you're in Bryn Mawr and craving an unforgettable pizza experience, Lovecchio's is a slice above the rest! 🍕💖

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Willow Grove.

il Fiore

At il Fiore, each bite is a delightful journey! The crust is perfectly crisp, yet it has a lovely chew that makes you want to savor it. I tried the Margherita pizza, and the fresh mozzarella combined with aromatic basil and tangy tomato sauce created a symphony of flavors. What truly sets this place apart is their commitment to quality ingredients, which is evident in every slice. The ambiance is delightful, adding to the overall experience. If you’re in Bryn Mawr, don’t miss the chance to indulge in this pizza perfection; it’s a slice of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best cookies in Philadelphia.

Pizzarella Grille

Pizzarella Grille has quickly become a favorite of mine! The moment I walked in, the tantalizing aroma enveloped me, sparking my enthusiasm for their artisanal creations. I decided on their Margherita pizza, featuring a perfectly charred crust that offered a delightful crunch. The balance of fresh basil, zesty tomatoes, and creamy mozzarella was nothing short of sublime. Each bite felt like a celebration of classic flavors, elegantly presented. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff only added to the charm. If you're seeking a slice of heaven in Bryn Mawr, Pizzarella Grille is a must-try—you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Philadelphia.

La Cabra Brewing Smokehouse

Nestled in the heart of Bryn Mawr, La Cabra Brewing Smokehouse offers a delightful twist on classic pizza. Their wood-fired pies boast a crispy crust, perfectly charred and topped with vibrant, fresh ingredients. I sampled the smoky margherita, and wow—the meld of earthy basil and tangy sauce was simply divine! Each bite showcases a commitment to quality and artistry that is hard to resist. Plus, the relaxed atmosphere and local brews provide the perfect pairing. If you're in the mood for a pie that’s both inventive and comforting, La Cabra is definitely worth a visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best butchers in Philadelphia.

Zesto Pizza and Grill

Zesto Pizza and Grill in Bryn Mawr is a delightful discovery for any pizza lover! I was immediately drawn in by the aroma of freshly baked dough and tangy sauce. I indulged in their classic Margherita pizza, which was a joyful harmony of flavors, topped with vibrant basil and creamy mozzarella that literally melted in my mouth. The crust was a perfect balance of crispy and chewy — a true masterpiece! The charming atmosphere and friendly staff only added to the experience. If you’re seeking a slice of pizzalicious heaven, make your way to Zesto and let your taste buds celebrate! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Philadelphia.