Somewhere between the Lollipop Motel’s spotless kitchenette and the chaos of the Montego Bay boardwalk, there is very good pizza. You just have to walk past a few sad slices to find it.

North Wildwood rewards the stubborn, the ones willing to trek to the end of the boards for a properly charred crust or order a pierogi break before the next pie. I have eaten my weight in crab cakes at Dogtooth and nearly cried when La Siciliana closed temporarily.

Do not skip the meatballs at Al's. The list below is the truth, no sugarcoating.

Go eat.

Kimberly's

Highlights
Family-run, heartfelt hospitality
Breakfast burrito worth returning for
Dinner steaks cooked perfectly
Anniversary cheesecake on the house

Kimberly's is the kind of place that makes you feel like you crashed a family dinner, and I mean that as a compliment. The hospitality is heartfelt, not performative. I came for the pizza, but the breakfast burrito stole the morning. Dinner steaks arrived cooked exactly as ordered, no small miracle at the shore. On our anniversary, they brought out cheesecake on the house. I didn't ask for it. They just knew. That's the kind of attention that keeps me coming back. The pie itself is solid, honest work. Nothing fancy. Just good food from people who care. That counts for a lot in this town.

You might also want to check out the best casino in Atlantic City.

Aloha Oceanfront Motel

Highlights
Friendly, funny front desk staff
Spacious rooms with ample seating
Clean, cheerful family atmosphere
Convenient attached luncheonette

The Aloha Oceanfront Motel isn't a pizza joint, but I'm including it because you need a base camp for your pizza pilgrimage. The front desk staff are friendly and genuinely funny, which is rarer than you'd think. Rooms are spacious with ample seating, so you can spread out your slices and judge them properly. The place is clean and cheerful, and the whole vibe screams family vacation without the chaos. There's a convenient attached luncheonette for quick bites. I stayed, I ate, I slept well. You could do far worse. The hospitality sets the tone for the whole trip.

You might also want to check out the best food in Cape May.

Dogtooth Bar & Grill

Highlights
Fast, fresh lunch service
Best crab cakes around
Strong, balanced margaritas
Crowd-pleasing menu options
Fair prices for quality

Dogtooth Bar & Grill handles lunch with impressive speed, and the food arrives fresh. The crab cakes are the best around, and I've eaten a lot of crab cakes in my day. Their margaritas are strong and balanced, not that syrupy nonsense you get elsewhere. The menu is a crowd-pleaser, which usually worries me, but the execution holds up. Prices are fair for the quality, which is almost an insult to other places charging more for less. I walked in hungry and left satisfied. That's the whole job. They do it well. I'll be back when I need a break from pizza.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Atlantic City.

The Pierogie Place

Highlights
Plump, warm, comforting pierogies
Unique vegan cheddar filling
Quick, polite, accurate service
Chili oil pairing recommended
Worth a boardwalk return

The Pierogie Place sits right on the boardwalk, and the pierogies are plump, warm, and deeply comforting. I tried the vegan cheddar filling, and it surprised me. Rich, creamy, no sacrifice in flavor. The service is quick, polite, and accurate, which is a rare combination in a tourist zone. They suggested chili oil on top, and I scoffed until I tried it. Good call. The whole experience warrants a return trip on your next boardwalk stroll. It's not pizza, but it's a worthy detour. Sometimes you need a dumpling break before you hit another slice.

You might also want to check out the best food in Staten Island.

Hassles Ice Cream

Highlights
Allergy-safe ice cream options
Dedicated cross-contamination protocols
Fantastic dairy-free selection
Decades of consistent quality
Long evening lines, worth it

Hassles Ice Cream has been doing this for decades, and the line out front proves it. Long evening lines, but worth every minute. They offer allergy-safe options with dedicated cross-contamination protocols, which matters if you're eating with someone who has issues. The dairy-free selection is fantastic, not an afterthought. I had a cone that tasted better than most full-dairy versions. The consistency over the years is remarkable. Some places coast on reputation. This place earns its queue nightly. I stood there, grumbling about the wait, then took one bite and shut up. That's the highest praise I can give.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Chelsea.

Lollipop Motel

Highlights
Spotless rooms, fair price
Owner Angie truly cares
Spacious kitchenette and living room
Our go-to Wildwood stay

The Lollipop Motel is our go-to stay in Wildwood, and owner Angie is the reason why. She genuinely cares, and you can feel it in the spotless rooms. The price is fair, which is almost suspicious in this area. The kitchenette and living room are spacious, so you can actually spread out and enjoy your pizza leftovers. We've stayed here multiple times, and it never misses. Angie remembers our names. That kind of attention is rare. The place feels like a home away from home, minus the family drama. If you're looking for a clean, quiet base, this is it. I won't stay anywhere else.

You might also want to check out the best flower shop in Philadelphia.

Montego Bay Resort

Highlights
Decades-long family tradition destination
Prime beachfront boardwalk location
Kid-friendly with playful amenities
Upgraded rooms with kitchen access
On-site dining and holiday views

Montego Bay Resort is a decades-long family tradition for us, and it's easy to see why. The beachfront boardwalk location is prime, and the place is kid-friendly with playful amenities that keep the little ones busy. We upgraded to a room with kitchen access, which meant we could reheat slices properly. On-site dining saves you a walk when you're tired. The holiday views from the room are a bonus. It's busy, sure, but the chaos feels managed. Staff keep things running smooth. This isn't a quiet retreat. It's a vibrant, noisy, fun resort. But sometimes that's exactly what a pizza vacation needs.

You might also want to check out the best wings in Philadelphia.

La Siciliana By Dolce Italia

Highlights
Decades of repeated visits
Best pizza we’ve had
Whole pie devoured quickly
Chicken Parm also great
Glad they reopened

La Siciliana By Dolce Italia: I've been coming here for decades, and it's still the best pizza I've had. Period. The whole pie got devoured quickly, which says more than any review could. The crust has that perfect chew, the sauce is bright, the cheese is properly melty. I once ordered the Chicken Parm, and it was also great. They closed for a while, and I panicked. Glad they reopened. This is the benchmark I measure all other North Wildwood slices against. Most fail. This one doesn't. If you only eat one pizza on your trip, make it here. You'll thank me later.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in West Chester.

Al The STK & Pizza King

Highlights
Philly and sushi roll
Pizza that hits right
Crab cakes, pork chop Milanese
Meatballs worth returning for
A stop you repeat

Al The STK & Pizza King is a stop you repeat, and I don't use that phrase lightly. The pizza hits right, with a solid crust and honest toppings. But the menu is wild. A Philly cheesesteak and sushi roll on the same menu? I tried both. No regrets. The crab cakes are solid, and the pork chop Milanese is a surprise winner. The meatballs are worth returning for alone. This place is a chaotic mashup of cuisines, and somehow it all works. Portions are generous. Prices are fair. I walked out full, confused, and happy. That's the ideal restaurant experience, if you ask me.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo shops in Philadelphia.

Toscana Pizzeria

Highlights
Crispy, well-done crust perfection
Quality cheese and sauce ratio
Fair portion for the price
Boardwalk end worth the walk
Demolishes area slice rivals

Toscana Pizzeria sits at the boardwalk end, and the walk is worth it. The crust is crispy, well done, and perfect. The cheese to sauce ratio is quality, not overloaded with grease. Portion is fair for the price, which is rare in tourist spots. This slice demolishes area rivals. I've had floppy, sad slices elsewhere. This one stands up. The char on the crust gives it character. You can tell someone actually cares about the bake. If you're walking the boards and want a real slice, skip the closer places. Make the trek. Your taste buds will thank you, even if your feet complain.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artist in Philadelphia.

Poppi's Brick Oven Pizza & Kitchen

Highlights
Best antipasto around
Dog-friendly outdoor patio
Phenomenal service always
Food improves every visit

Poppi's Brick Oven Pizza & Kitchen keeps improving every time I visit, and I've visited a lot. The service is phenomenal, always warm and attentive. They have the best antipasto around, loaded with good stuff. The outdoor patio is dog-friendly, so I can bring my mutt and not feel guilty. I sat outside, ate my pie, and watched the world go by. The brick oven crust has that smoky edge you can't fake. Prices are reasonable. The staff remember your order. That attention to detail is rare. This place has become a habit. A good habit. The kind you don't want to break.

You might also want to check out the best b&b in Cape May.

Crazy Junky

Highlights
Quick service, large portions
Generous value for price
Friendly, accommodating staff
Memorable Middle Eastern specialties
Thoughtful customer care

Crazy Junky serves quick, and the portions are large. Generous value for the price, which makes me suspicious until I taste it. The staff are friendly and accommodating, and they actually listen when you ask for something. The Middle Eastern specialties were memorable, with flavors that stuck with me longer than the meal. I wasn't expecting much from a place with a name like that. I was wrong. They also showed thoughtful customer care, checking in without hovering. It's not pizza, but it's worth a stop. If you're tired of slices, this is the change of pace you need. Just go hungry.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Bethlehem.